As the wedding bells draw near, budding writer Paulie finds himself on the brink of adulthood, navigating the challenges of responsibility with his expectant fiancée Sue by his side. He stands at a crucial intersection where the roles of fatherhood, honesty, and masculinity intertwine, putting him face-to-face with the complexities and realities of life.

Adding another layer to this emotional journey is Paulie’s older brother Jimbo, whose own marriage hangs in the balance. Jimbo offers a brutally honest perspective on Paulie’s impending marriage, fueled by a mix of jealousy over Paulie’s perceived stability and resentment for his own failures in providing for his family. As their relationship becomes increasingly strained, Paulie is forced to balance Jimbo’s advice with his own personal desires and sense of responsibility.

Just when the wedding preparations seem to be reaching their peak, a figure from the past, T.C., emerges from the shadows, bringing a suitcase full of secrets that shake the very foundation of their lives. His return revives a long-festering conflict involving Paulie’s cousin Mike, who still harbors resentment over the theft of his prized Tom Seaver baseball card—an incident deeply intertwined with T.C.’s mysterious and hasty exit eight years prior.

As the layers of truth start to peel away, T.C.’s departure is revealed to be ignited by a profound epiphany about his identity and belonging. Initially perceived as a thoughtless act, stealing Mike’s card emerged from a more desperate need to escape a toxic atmosphere. The local bar, owned by the ever-hopeful Dez, becomes an unlikely venue for self-exploration, as T.C.’s homecoming underscores how difficult it is to come to terms with one’s true self.

With the spotlight on the upcoming wedding, Paulie along with his friends are compelled to confront their inner demons, reassess their bonds, and ultimately reconcile their pasts with their futures. Amidst the swirling chaos of emotions and revelations, Dez remains the steadfast figure rallying support and cherishing the concept of “getting the band back together”—a phrase that evolves into a reminder of the group’s struggle toward personal growth and the ever-changing dynamics of their friendships.