Ad Blocker Detected

We use ads to keep this site running, so please consider disabling your ad blocker. Thank you!

Do not know how to disable ad blocker? Check out this article: How to disable ad blocker?

The Old Way

The Old Way 2023

Test your knowledge of The Old Way with our quiz!

Plot Summary

Discover the intricate plot of The Old Way (2023). From unexpected twists to emotional highs and lows, this detailed summary breaks down every moment to give you a deeper understanding of the film’s story.


In the year 1878, within the rugged expanse of the Montana Territory, gunfighter Colton Briggs finds himself part of an extrajudicial posse tasked with capturing and executing Walter McAllister, a notorious bandit’s brother. However, plans take a violent turn when Walter and his gang attempt to thwart the public execution, sparking a relentless shootout that results in only Colton and Walter’s son, James surviving the chaos. In an emotional moment, Colton promises to spare Walter’s brother, using his execution as a mere ruse to draw out Walter. Yet, the younger McAllister, filled with rage, attempts to ambush Colton but is swiftly gunned down, leaving a lasting impression on young James.

Fast forward twenty years, and Colton is no longer the ruthless gunfighter he once was. Influenced by his loving wife Ruth, he has transformed into a respected merchant, running a general store and maintaining a modest farm where he raises their rebellious twelve-year-old daughter, Brooke. Sadly, Brooke’s defiant demeanor and emotional detachment are stark reminders of her father’s tumultuous past. One dreadful day, their peaceful lives are shattered when James McAllister returns, leading his gang to their farm, brutally murdering Ruth, and scrawling a taunting message in her blood before retreating.

As they mourn Ruth, they meet Franklin Jarret, the U.S. Marshal, who had once shared a close camaraderie with Colton. Jarret praises Colton for abandoning his violent ways but warns him against seeking vengeance. Despite his friend’s advice, vengeance consumes Colton, and he decides to take Brooke with him. He dons his old gunfighter attire, armed with pistols, and sets ablaze their home, marking the end of his peaceful life.

As they pursue answers, Colton and Brooke manage to confront Jarret once more, discovering that James plans to escape to Santa Rosa, Colorado, to retrieve a hidden stash of pesos. Determined, Colton warns Jarret not to interfere with his plans. In the town of Santa Rosa, while Colton waits outside, Brooke tries to gather intel from a local shopkeeper but is captured by James.

Brimming with his old skills, Colton skillfully dispatches members of the McAllister gang, culminating in a tense standoff where James presents him with a brutal choice: kill him, and Brooke dies, or sacrifice himself. In a calculated move, Colton takes down the second man, only to take a bullet from James. In an unexpected turn of events, Brooke, who has been honing her shooting skills, heroically picks up her father’s gun and avenges him, killing James.

As the dust settles, Jarret arrives and concocts a cover story to preserve Colton’s legacy, claiming he died heroically while apprehending criminals. Unbeknownst to Jarret, however, Brooke cleverly conceals a large sum of the McAllister gang’s money and sets her sights on returning home, leaving viewers eager to see how their story unfolds.

Timeline

Track the key events of The Old Way (2023) with a comprehensive timeline. Perfect for understanding the sequence of major plot points, this feature offers clarity on how the story unfolds.


Colton Joins the Posse

In 1878, Colton Briggs becomes part of an extrajudicial posse tasked with capturing Walter McAllister, a notorious bandit. This decision marks the beginning of a series of violent events that will forever alter the lives of those involved.

1878 Montana Territory

The Shootout Begins

The plans for Walter’s execution devolve into chaos when he and his gang attempt to rescue him. A relentless gunfight ensues, resulting in heavy casualties, with only Colton and Walter's son, James, managing to survive the brutality.

Montana Territory

A Promise of Mercy

In the aftermath of the shootout, Colton promises to spare Walter's brother, using the execution as bait to draw Walter out. This moment foreshadows the complex relationship between Colton and the McAllister family.

James' Fatal Ambush

Consumed by rage over his father's plight, James attempts to ambush Colton but meets a swift end. This event leaves a deep impression on young James, shaping his future decisions and actions.

The Passage of Time

Fast forward twenty years, Colton has abandoned his gunfighter ways after marrying Ruth and starting a new life. However, the shadows of his violent past linger on, especially in the rebellious nature of their daughter, Brooke.

20 years later

Tragedy Strikes

Colton's peaceful life is shattered when James McAllister returns with his gang. In a brutal attack on their farm, Ruth is murdered, and a taunting message is left behind, sending Colton into a spiral of grief.

Colton's farm

Meeting Franklin Jarret

In the midst of their mourning, Colton and Brooke encounter Franklin Jarret, the U.S. Marshal. Jarret praises Colton for leaving behind violence but warns him against seeking revenge, highlighting the internal struggle Colton faces.

The Call for Vengeance

Ignoring Jarret's well-meaning advice, vengeance overtakes Colton. He decides to take Brooke along and puts on his old gunfighter attire, symbolizing his return to a violent life as he sets their home ablaze.

Colton's farm

The Hunt for James

Colton and Brooke learn that James is headed to Santa Rosa, Colorado, to retrieve a hidden stash of pesos. Armed with this knowledge, Colton sets out determined to confront James and avenge Ruth's death.

Santa Rosa

Captured in Santa Rosa

While Colton waits outside in Santa Rosa, Brooke attempts to gather information from a shopkeeper. Unfortunately, she is captured by James, heightening the stakes for Colton as he prepares to confront his nemesis.

Santa Rosa

The Standoff

In a tense showdown, Colton faces off against James and his gang. James offers him a horrific choice: kill him and lose Brooke, or sacrifice himself, testing Colton's resolve and commitment to his daughter.

Brooke's Heroic Moment

As Colton takes a bullet from James, Brooke, having secretly honed her shooting skills, bravely picks up her father's gun. She avenges her father by killing James, showcasing her growth and determination.

Jarret's Cover Story

Following the chaos, Franklin Jarret arrives at the scene. To protect Colton’s legacy, he concocts a cover story claiming that Colton died heroically while apprehending criminals, highlighting the dichotomy of truth and heroism.

Brooke's Secret Plans

Unbeknownst to Jarret, Brooke cleverly conceals a significant amount of the McAllister gang’s money. With a newfound resolve, she sets her sights on returning home, leaving an air of mystery about her future.

Characters

Meet the characters that bring The Old Way (2023) to life. Dive into detailed profiles of the cast and their roles, exploring their motivations, relationships, and arcs within the story.


Colton Briggs (Nicolas Cage)

Once a ruthless gunfighter, Colton has attempted to leave his violent past behind and embrace a peaceful life as a merchant. However, the murder of his wife forces him back into his old ways, revealing a complex character torn between vengeance and paternal duty.

⚔️ Gunfighter 🤠 Merchant 😢 Grief

Brooke Briggs (Ryan Kiera Armstrong)

Brooke is a rebellious twelve-year-old caught in the shadow of her father's tumultuous past. Her emotional detachment and defiance reflect the pain of familial loss, yet she ultimately transforms through hardship, emerging as a courageous figure by the film's end.

👧 Daughter 🥁 Rebellious 🏹 Brave

Ruth Briggs (Kerry Knuppe)

Ruth is the loving wife of Colton and a stabilizing force in his life. Her brutal murder is the catalyst that drives Colton back into a violent path, showcasing the profound impact of her character on the storyline and her family's fate.

💖 Wife 🏠 Caretaker 😢 Loss

James McAllister (Noah Le Gros)

James, fueled by rage and revenge, represents the cycle of violence that defines his family. His actions serve as the main antagonist to Colton's journey, culminating in a tragic confrontation that forces both characters to confront their shared past.

🔫 Antagonist ⚔️ Vengeful 😡 Anger

Setting

Uncover the settings of The Old Way (2023), from iconic locations to the time period that shapes its world. See how these elements add depth and context to the movie’s narrative.


Time period

1878, 20 years later

The movie begins in 1878, a time marked by lawlessness and violence in the American West, where gunfighters like Colton Briggs operate outside the law. Fast forward twenty years, the timeline brings the audience into a more settled era, but the specter of the past lingers as old rivalries and vendettas resurface.

Location

Montana Territory, Santa Rosa, Colorado

The rugged Montana Territory, characterized by its wild landscapes and harsh conditions, serves as the backdrop for the film, providing a stark contrast to Colton's later life as a merchant. Santa Rosa, Colorado, represents a changing world where Colton encounters his past and faces the consequences of his former life as a gunfighter.

🏞️ Wilderness 🏙️ Town

Themes

Explore the core themes of The Old Way (2023). From its commentary on social issues to its emotional undertones, delve into the deeper messages woven into the film’s story.


⚔️

Revenge

Revenge permeates the film as Colton is driven by the brutal murder of his wife, leading him back to a path of violence he had long abandoned. This powerful theme highlights the cycle of vengeance, showcasing how the quest for retribution can overshadow personal growth and peace.

👨‍👧

Family Bonds

The relationship between Colton and Brooke illustrates the complexities of family ties, especially within the context of trauma and loss. Their journey reveals the impact of a violent heritage on the younger generation, emphasizing the struggle to forge one's identity amidst familial legacies.

💔

Loss

Loss is a central theme, deeply affecting Colton and Brooke after the death of Ruth. This tragedy spurs Colton back into his past life while Brooke must contend with both her grief and the harsh reality of her family's violent history, shaping her character's development.

© 2025 What's After the Movie?. All rights reserved.