A Different Man 2024
Directed by
Aaron Schimberg
Made by
A24
Plot Summary
Edward Lemuel is a struggling actor with neurofibromatosis that manifests as a disfiguring facial condition. He befriends his new neighbor Ingrid Vold, an aspiring playwright, but is too nervous to act on his romantic feelings towards her. After receiving an experimental medical treatment that cures him of his condition, he assumes the identity of “Guy Moratz” and claims that Edward has killed himself.
Sometime later, “Guy” is now a wealthy and successful real estate agent. One day, he discovers that Ingrid is producing Edward, a off-Broadway play she has written based on his life; he auditions and is cast in the lead role. Edward and Ingrid begin a sexual relationship soon thereafter, though Ingrid remains unaware of the truth of his identity. During rehearsals they are visited by Oswald, a man with neurofibromatosis who has taken an interest in the play. The confident and charismatic Oswald quickly befriends the cast and crew, although Edward is perturbed by his outgoing demeanor.
Ingrid and Oswald grow closer, and after Edward is unable to memorize his lines, she decides to recast Oswald in the lead role. The play is a success, and Oswald’s performance receives rave reviews. Edward’s mental state begins to deteriorate: he begins stalking Oswald, is fired from his real estate job, and eventually storms the stage of the play one night to physically attack Oswald. During the scuffle, part of the set falls on Edward, breaking his legs and arms. While he recovers from his injuries he moves back into his former apartment next to Ingrid, who is now living with Oswald and making plans to adapt Edward into a film. One day, after Edward’s physical therapist expresses disgust for Oswald behind his back, Edward stabs him and is jailed.
Years later, an aged Edward once again encounters Oswald. He has dinner with Oswald and Ingrid, now a married and highly successful creative duo who are planning their retirement to a commune in Canada. A waiter arrives to take their orders, but a visibly nervous Edward struggles to choose from the menu. Oswald jokes that Edward hasn’t changed a bit.
Timeline
Edward's Condition
Edward Lemuel struggles with neurofibromatosis, resulting in a disfigured facial appearance that greatly impacts his confidence. This condition has hindered his acting career, leaving him feeling isolated and insecure about his future.
Meeting Ingrid
Edward befriends his new neighbor, Ingrid Vold, who is an aspiring playwright. Despite their growing friendship, Edward feels unable to express his romantic feelings for her, creating tension and uncertainty between them.
Experimental Treatment
Edward undergoes an experimental medical treatment that miraculously cures his neurofibromatosis. With his newfound confidence, he adopts the false identity of 'Guy Moratz' and publicly claims that his former self, Edward, has committed suicide.
Success as Guy
As 'Guy Moratz', Edward finds success as a wealthy real estate agent, living a life that contrasts sharply with his former struggles. However, his past continues to haunt him, especially when he learns about Ingrid's new play based on his life.
Audition for Edward
Ingrid is producing an off-Broadway play titled 'Edward', inspired by Edward's life. Seizing the opportunity, Edward auditions and is oddly cast in the lead role, deepening his complicated feelings for Ingrid while still hiding his true identity.
Romantic Involvement
As rehearsals progress, Edward and Ingrid begin a sexual relationship, though Ingrid remains unaware that 'Guy' is actually Edward. This deception adds layers of complexity to their relationship, as Edward grapples with his hidden identity.
Oswald's Arrival
Oswald, a man with neurofibromatosis, visits during rehearsals and quickly charms the cast. Edward feels threatened by Oswald's outgoing nature and his burgeoning connection with Ingrid, sparking jealousy and discomfort.
Recasting the Role
Ingrid ultimately decides to recast Oswald in the lead role after noticing Edward's struggles with memorizing his lines. The decision devastates Edward and marks a turning point in his mental state as he grapples with feelings of inadequacy.
The Play's Success
The play opens to great acclaim, and Oswald's performance earns rave reviews. Edward's envy and mental deterioration escalate as he can't accept being overshadowed by Oswald's talent and bond with Ingrid.
Stage Confrontation
In a fit of rage, Edward storms the stage during a performance and physically confronts Oswald. This explosive encounter leads to a tragic accident where part of the set collapses, resulting in serious injuries to Edward.
Recovery and Isolation
After sustaining multiple fractures, Edward returns to his old apartment while recovering from his injuries. During this time, he discovers that Ingrid and Oswald are growing closer and making plans to adapt 'Edward' into a film.
The Stabbing Incident
Enraged by his situation and spurred on by a conversation with his physical therapist who disparages Oswald, Edward stabs Oswald, leading to his arrest and imprisonment. This violent act marks a stark descent into violence for Edward.
Years Later Encounter
Years pass, and an aged Edward crosses paths with Oswald once again. He joins Oswald and Ingrid, who are now a successful creative couple planning their retirement, highlighting the stark contrast to Edward's life.
Dinner Meeting
During a tense dinner, Edward struggles to fit into the social dynamic, feeling out of place among the accomplished duo. Oswald makes light-hearted jokes, but Edward's anxiety hints that he remains deeply affected by the events of the past.
Final Reflection
As the waiter arrives to take their orders, Edward's nervousness becomes palpable, serving as a poignant reminder of how much he has changed and yet remained the same. Oswald's jest about Edward's unchanged nature underlines the complexity of their intertwined lives.
Characters
Edward Lemuel / Guy Moratz (Sebastian Stan)
Edward is a complex character defined by his struggles with neurofibromatosis, which leads to profound insecurities and the ultimate desire for acceptance. His transformation into Guy Moratz represents a tumultuous journey filled with ambition, jealousy, and ultimately tragedy as he grapples with his identity and relationships.
Ingrid Vold (Renate Reinsve)
Ingrid is an aspiring playwright who embodies determination and creativity. Her relationship with Edward reveals her vulnerability as she navigates the complexities of love and artistic integrity, particularly as she unwittingly becomes entangled in Edward's deception.
Oswald (Adam Pearson)
Oswald is portrayed as a confident and charismatic figure who inspires and challenges Edward’s understanding of identity and acceptance. His outward demeanor and eventual success in the play position him as both a rival and a mirror to Edward's insecurities.
Setting
Time period
The movie spans various years, showcasing the progression of Edward's life from a struggling actor to a successful real estate agent and back again. The personal transformations and emotional turmoil depicted resonate across a timeless exploration of identity and ambition.
Location
New York City, Canada
The movie primarily takes place in New York City, known for its vibrant arts scene and as a hub for theater productions, particularly off-Broadway. The story also extends to a commune in Canada, symbolizing a place of tranquility and escape for the characters as they contemplate retirement.
Themes
🎭
Identity
The theme of identity runs deeply throughout the film as Edward grapples with his self-worth and how he is perceived by others. After his transformation, he assumes a new identity as 'Guy Moratz', leading to a conflict between his true self and the persona he presents to the world.
❤️
Love and Betrayal
The complicated relationship between Edward and Ingrid explores the nuances of love and betrayal. As Edward falls in love with Ingrid, he is forced to navigate the precarious balance between deception and honesty, highlighting how love can lead to both connection and heartache.
💔
Jealousy
Jealousy becomes a driving force in Edward's actions, particularly as he watches Oswald's success and his growing bond with Ingrid. This emotion pushes Edward to desperate measures, culminating in his violent outburst and further spiraling into chaos.
Featured on this page
What's After the Movie?
Not sure whether to stay after the credits? Find out!
Check out our other apps:
Actors
Companies
Latest Movies
© 2024 What's After the Movie?. All rights reserved.