The Alto Knights 2025

In a failed assassination attempt orchestrated by his ambitious underboss, Vito Genovese, Luciano family boss Frank Costello finds himself at a crossroads. Weary of the constant bloodshed and betrayals that define his life, Costello informs Genovese of his intention to retire and cede control of the Luciano family. However, Vito, a man consumed by ambition and paranoia, refuses to believe Costello’s intentions, suspecting a ruse. The poisoned well of distrust between them spills over, igniting a silent, deadly war.

Genovese’s suspicion curdles into outright aggression when he orchestrates the brutal murder of Albert Anastasia, Costello’s chosen successor, while he is sitting in a barber’s chair. This act of shocking violence shatters the fragile peace and forces Costello to confront a terrifying reality: his life, and the life of his beloved wife, are hanging by a thread. He realizes that the only way to ensure their safety is to dismantle the entire operation he painstakingly built, to tear down the empire that now threatens to consume him.

Costello understands that Genovese, driven by his overwhelming paranoia, sees him as a lingering threat to his true intention: to seize outright control of the Five Families as capo dei capi. In Genovese’s twisted mind, Costello’s perceived “mild-mannered” nature is simply a deceptive façade, masking a cunning and vengeful spirit poised to strike back for the failed hit. However, unlike Genovese, Costello is not governed by crude ambition and is willing to play the long game.

Costello formulates a plan, one arguably more audacious than a simple act of retribution within the mafia’s brutal code. He eschews the traditional route of murder, recognizing that Vito has gained too many powerful allies who would surely seek vengeance. Instead, Costello opts for a more subtle, insidious approach, leveraging the increased scrutiny already focused on the mafia to orchestrate Genovese’s incarceration.

The linchpin of Costello’s plan lies in the fateful Apalachin meeting. While never definitively proven, circumstantial evidence suggests that Costello tipped off law enforcement, alerting them to the gathering of powerful mafia figures in the small New York town of Apalachin, where Vito intends to legitimize his new position. Costello furthers the deception by deliberately delaying his arrival, making conspicuous coffee stops and engaging in leisurely apple-picking, all in an attempt to buy time for the authorities to arrive. His almost comical behavior, however, doesn’t go unnoticed, sparking suspicion in his driver.

The assembled mobsters are caught completely off guard, panic, and attempt to flee through the woods, leaving a trail of evidence behind. Law enforcement meticulously recorded license plate numbers, leading to the indictment and conviction of twenty attendees on conspiracy to obstruct justice charges for providing false statements about the purpose of the clandestine gathering. The raid at Apalachin exposed the inner workings of the American Mafia to the public, drawing unprecedented scrutiny and ultimately contributing to Vito’s downfall several years later when he is formally convicted of dealing in heroin. Costello, on the other hand, achieves his dream of a peaceful retirement and dies an old man.