On the fateful evening of November 14, 1970, Southern Airways Flight 932, a chartered McDonnell Douglas DC-9 carrying the Thundering Herd football team back to Huntington, West Virginia, following a tight 17-14 loss to the East Carolina University Pirates, tragically clipped trees on a ridge just one mile from Tri-State Airport. The flight ultimately crashed into a nearby gully, resulting in a heartbreaking loss of all 75 souls onboard.

Among the deceased were 37 players, head coach Rick Tolley (portrayed by Robert Patrick), five coaching staff members, Marshall’s athletic director Charles E. Kautz, athletic trainer Jim Schroer, assistant trainer Donald Tackett, sports information director and radio announcer Gene Morehouse, along with 25 boosters and five crew members.

In the wake of this catastrophic loss, a remarkable story of resilience unfolded. That spring, player Nate Ruffin (Anthony Mackie), who missed the tragic flight due to an illness, led a passionate campaign among the students to persuade the board of governors to allow the team to play the 1971 season. Despite the tragic events, University President Donald Dedmon initially leaned towards suspending the football program indefinitely. However, the heartfelt pleas from Marshall students and Huntington residents, particularly the surviving players, encouraged him to reconsider.

In a bid to revitalize the program, Dedmon hired Jack Lengyel (Matthew McConaughey) as the new head coach. Alongside Red Dawson (Matthew Fox), one of the two surviving coaching staff members, they faced the daunting task of rebuilding the team with limited resources and experience. As prospects dwindled—many opting to join West Virginia University instead—Dedmon traveled to Kansas City to appeal to the NCAA to lift restrictions prohibiting freshmen from playing varsity football. His efforts were rewarded when he returned victorious.

Under the leadership of Lengyel, the young players were motivated not only to play but to redefine what it meant to compete. He challenged the old coaching paradigms, employing every possible strategy, even resorting to visiting rival coaches to obtain insights for his playbook. The reformed team consisted primarily of the 18 returning players—three from varsity and 15 sophomores—along with walk-on athletes from various sports at Marshall University.

Their debut was bittersweet; the “Young Thundering Herd” suffered a 29-6 defeat to the Morehead State Eagles. The loss weighed heavily on both Dawson and Ruffin, with many questioning whether it was disrespectful to field a team so inexperienced. Nevertheless, Lengyel remained undeterred, recognizing the unwavering support from the community. This determination culminated in a stunning comeback victory during their first home game against Xavier University, where they triumphed 15-13, reigniting the town’s spirit and honoring the memories of the fallen teammates.

Although they did not secure another win for the remainder of the season, the perseverance displayed laid the groundwork for extraordinary success in the following decades, culminating in five championships during the 1980s. This remarkable journey is a testament to the courage of those who fought to keep the football program alive against all odds.