Test your knowledge of Leatherheads with our quiz!

Plot Summary


In the year 1925, we follow Jimmy “Dodge” Connelly, the seasoned captain of the Duluth Bulldogs, a struggling professional American football team. As the future of pro football hangs by a thread, Dodge is resolute in his mission to revitalize the sport. He lures renowned Princeton football star, Carter “the Bullet” Rutherford—a celebrated hero of World War I—to join the Bulldogs, believing that leveraging Carter’s fame will bring prosperity to the game.

Meanwhile, Lexie Littleton, a sharp reporter for the Chicago Tribune, is tasked with uncovering the truth behind Carter’s supposedly heroic exploits. However, her investigation takes an unexpected turn as she finds herself entwined in a love triangle with both Dodge and Carter. One fateful night, Carter reveals that the German platoon actually surrendered to him by mistake, igniting a conflict when Lexie’s hidden motives become clear, including a kiss shared with Dodge.

As the publication of Lexie’s story creates a storm of controversy, accusations fly and Carter’s manager resorts to questionable tactics to suppress the truth, even going so far as to bribe witnesses. The efforts to salvage pro football grow desperate as the new commissioner, appointed by the U.S. Congress, establishes formal rules that stifle the game’s creative spirit while also tackling the growing scandal surrounding Carter.

Caught in the turmoil, Dodge devises a clever scheme, interrupting a private hearing in the commissioner’s office. He threatens Carter with a confrontation from his old army comrades who he claims are waiting just outside to commend him for his bravery. In a surprising twist, these so-called comrades turn out to be Bulldogs dressed in army uniforms. Facing the pressure, Carter finally confesses, leading the commissioner to release Lexie from the obligation of retracting her story. As a result, Carter must admit to receiving undue credit for his wartime actions and donate a considerable portion of his earnings to the American Legion, while his unscrupulous manager faces a lifetime ban from football.

As the final game approaches, Dodge finds himself on the field against Carter, who has switched allegiance from Duluth to Chicago. Tensions rise as both men vie for Lexie’s heart amidst an electrifying showdown. In a chaotic match where rules seem nonexistent, an unexpected twist unfolds. After a fierce brawl, Dodge cleverly disguises himself as a Chicago player, ultimately leading to a crucial touchdown that secures victory for the Bulldogs.

In the aftermath, Carter plans to reveal the true story of his time in the war, while Dodge presents an impassioned plea for the need for heroes in America. Ultimately, they part ways amicably, allowing for personal growth and reconciliation.

As the credits roll, we witness a montage of joyful moments: Dodge and Lexie riding off on his motorbike into the sunset, their wedding celebrations, and Carter’s generous donation of $10,000 to the American Legion, alongside his former manager now managing baseball legends Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig.

Timeline


Introduction to Dodge

In the year 1925, we meet Jimmy 'Dodge' Connelly, the seasoned captain of the Duluth Bulldogs, a struggling professional football team. Dodge is determined to save pro football from its declining state while ensuring the team's survival.

1925 Duluth

Recruiting Carter

Dodge decides to recruit renowned Princeton football star, Carter 'the Bullet' Rutherford, who is also a celebrated World War I hero. He believes that Carter's fame will revitalize interest in the sport and bring prosperity to their struggling team.

Lexie's Investigation

Lexie Littleton, a sharp reporter for the Chicago Tribune, is assigned to investigate Carter's war heroism. Her investigation leads her to question the authenticity of Carter's heroic exploits, setting the stage for the unfolding drama.

Chicago

Entangled in Romance

As Lexie delves into her investigation, she finds herself caught in a complicated love triangle involving both Dodge and Carter. The emotional dynamics complicate her professional obligations as she grows closer to both men.

Carter's Confession

One fateful night, during an intimate moment, Carter confesses to Lexie that the German platoon surrendered by mistake, exposing the cracks in his heroic facade. This revelation causes turmoil as Lexie's hidden intentions rise to the surface.

The Controversial Publication

Lexie's resulting article ignites a controversial debate surrounding Carter's heroism and the integrity of the sport. Accusations fly as Carter's manager attempts to suppress the truth by bribing witnesses, complicating the media frenzy.

The Commissioner’s Intervention

In response to the growing scandal, the U.S. Congress appoints a new football commissioner who establishes formal rules that challenge the innovative spirit of the game. He takes a stand against the controversies threatening the future of professional football.

Dodge's Bold Move

Amidst the chaos, Dodge interrupts a private hearing at the commissioner's office with a bold scheme. He threatens Carter by claiming that his old army comrades are outside, ready to confront him, dramatically escalating the stakes.

Commissioner's Office

The Truth is Revealed

Under pressure from Dodge's intimidation, Carter admits his exaggerated claims of heroism. The commissioner subsequently absolves Lexie from retracting her story, forcing Carter to acknowledge the truth and face the consequences.

The Final Game

As the final game arrives, tensions mount when Carter switches allegiance to the rival Chicago team, creating a personal showdown between him and Dodge. The game devolves into chaos, showcasing the desperation of both teams.

Football Field

Dodge's Disguise

In a surprising twist, Dodge disguises himself as a Chicago player amidst the chaos on the field. This clever tactic allows him to score a crucial touchdown, leading the Duluth Bulldogs to an unexpected victory.

Carter's Redemption

After the game, Carter decides to unveil the true story of his wartime experiences, embracing honesty for the first time. Meanwhile, Dodge advocates for the importance of heroes in America, highlighting the need for integrity.

Parting Ways

As the story concludes, Dodge and Carter part ways amicably, highlighting their personal growth through the events. They acknowledge each other's journey, suggesting a newfound respect despite their rivalry.

Final Montage

The credits roll over a montage showcasing joyful moments, including Dodge and Lexie riding into the sunset and their wedding festivities. Carter also donates $10,000 to the American Legion, demonstrating his commitment to making amends.

New Beginnings

The final scenes depict Carter's former manager transitioning to manage baseball legends Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig. This shift symbolizes new beginnings as each character moves forward in their respective lives.

Characters


Jimmy 'Dodge' Connelly (John Krasinski)

Jimmy 'Dodge' Connelly is the determined captain of the Duluth Bulldogs, showcasing leadership and resilience. His passion for football and commitment to reviving the sport reflect his deep belief in the game's potential, while his interactions with both Carter and Lexie reveal layers of vulnerability and ambition.

🏈 Leadership 💪 Determination

Carter 'the Bullet' Rutherford (George Clooney)

Carter is a charismatic former war hero, whose fame complicates his character. Despite his public persona, he struggles with the weight of his past actions, navigating the tension between his desire for recognition and the quest for authenticity, especially when confronted by the consequences of his earlier boasts.

🏅 Charisma ⚔️ Valor

Lexie Littleton

Lexie Littleton is a sharp and ambitious reporter whose investigative instincts lead her to uncover deeper truths. Her evolving relationship with Dodge and Carter complicates her professional integrity as she balances personal feelings with the quest for truth, making her a dynamic character torn between love and ambition.

📰 Journalism 💔 Conflict

Setting


Time period

1925

The year 1925 in America was marked by significant cultural shifts along with the rise of professional sports, particularly football. It was a time when societal changes led to increased interest in entertainment and the media, coinciding with the post-World War I era where heroes were celebrated and stories of valor were popular.

Location

Duluth, Chicago

Duluth is a city located on the shores of Lake Superior in Minnesota, known for its rich history in shipping and its passionate support for American football. Chicago, a bustling metropolis in Illinois, is renowned for its vibrant sports culture and historical significance in American sports, especially during the early 20th century.

🏙️ City 🏈 Sports

Themes


🏆

Heroism

The theme of heroism is central, as the characters navigate the complexities of fame and integrity. Dodge and Carter grapple with the consequences of their actions and the importance of genuine heroism, particularly in the face of media scrutiny and personal ambition.

❤️

Love Triangle

The love triangle between Dodge, Lexie, and Carter serves to heighten the emotional stakes in the narrative. It explores themes of loyalty, betrayal, and the quest for true connection amidst chaotic circumstances, demonstrating how personal relationships can be affected by external pressures.

📰

Truth vs. Deception

The struggle between truth and deception is a prevailing theme throughout the movie. As Lexie investigates Carter's past, the pursuit of truth becomes complicated by personal motives and societal expectations, highlighting the ethical dilemmas faced by those in the public eye.

© 2024 What's After the Movie?. All rights reserved.