Are We Good? (2025) – In‑Depth Reviews, Opinions & Critical Reception

Welcome to What’s After the Movie, your ultimate hub for movie summaries, box‑office data, quizzes, and deep‑dive analyses. Dive into our comprehensive look at the critical and audience response to the 2025 documentary Are We Good? – from Metacritic, Collider, Screen Rant, and more. Explore the full [movie page] for cast bios, trivia, and a detailed [summary] of the film.

---

Critical Consensus on Are We Good? (2025) – Overview

The documentary Are We Good? has sparked a vibrant conversation across the critical landscape. On Metacritic, the aggregate score hovers in the high 70s, reflecting a generally positive reception. Critics consistently laud the film’s raw intimacy and its willingness to confront grief without resorting to clichés. As Collider puts it, the film is “an enthralling look at pain, loss, and how we handle unexpected grief” while also delivering “surprises — both good and bad — that will certainly have you asking ‘WTF?’ throughout.”

Other outlets echo this sentiment. The Playlist highlights the documentary’s transcendence beyond “conventional biographical trappings” and describes it as “a roadmap through despair that refuses false consolation.” Meanwhile, Screen Rant praises the film as “a raw documentary exploring Marc Maron’s journey through grief and comedy, offering a holistic view of the beloved comedian/podcaster.”

The positive tone is reinforced by a slew of supportive voices: Blu‑ray.com, The Lamplight Review, Cinemasters, and Awards Radar all commend the film’s emotional weight, candidness, and its celebration of vulnerability in a culture that often demands male stoicism. Even reviewers who note minor flaws, like Avi Offer of NYC Movie Guru, acknowledge the documentary’s “intimate and candid” nature. Collectively, the critical consensus paints Are We Good? as a heartfelt, unflinching portrait that resonates strongly with anyone who has faced loss.

Explore more details, including full critic scores, on our [wiki] page for Are We Good? and check out related [profiles] of Marc Maron and director David Feiner.

---

Deep Dive into Critics’ Praise for the Documentary’s Emotional Honesty

The most lauded aspect of Are We Good? is its emotional honesty—a theme that surfaces repeatedly throughout the reviews. Jeanine T. Abraham of VisAbleBlackwoman calls it “the perfect documentary to watch right now,” emphasizing its timely relevance to audiences navigating personal grief. Brian Orndorf from Blu‑ray.com notes that the film “captures a time in this life that’s loaded with emotional weight and fear of the unknown,” praising director Feiner for “studying a man going through so much, maintaining a sense of humor as he processes all that he has and all that he’s lost.”

Brent Hankins of The Lamplight Review adds depth by stating, “There’s something valuable about watching someone with Maron’s reach acknowledge that grief doesn’t follow a tidy narrative arc, that working through trauma is messy and ongoing and sometimes embarrassing.” This observation dovetails with Rua Fay of Cinemasters, who points out the cultural significance: “In a culture that tells men to be stoic and unfeeling, it’s refreshing to see an entertainer be so vulnerable and open about grief.”

Critics also commend the documentary’s balance of humor and sorrow. Ross Bonaime (Collider) highlights the “surprises — both good and bad —” that keep viewers engaged, while Gregory Nussen (Screen Rant) praises the “holistic view” that intertwines Maron’s comedy with his mourning process. Even The Playlist’s Rodrigo Perez calls the film “a roadmap through despair that refuses false consolation,” underscoring its purposeful avoidance of saccharine optimism.

These praise points collectively illustrate why Are We Good? is being heralded as a benchmark for documentary storytelling that tackles mental health with nuance. For fans eager to explore Maron’s journey further, our [quiz page] offers a fun way to test your knowledge about the film’s key moments and themes.

---

Comparing Professional Critics vs. Audience Reactions

While critics have largely celebrated the documentary’s candidness, early audience reactions on platforms like Letterboxd and Rotten Tomatoes echo many of those sentiments, though they also surface a few divergent notes. The average user rating sits near the critics’ mean, indicating broad agreement on the film’s emotional resonance. Many viewers echo Ross Bonaime’s observation that the film “will certainly have you asking ‘WTF?’ throughout,” describing moments where Maron’s raw vulnerability catches them off‑guard.

However, a subset of audience members cited pacing concerns, echoing Avi Offer’s lukewarm comment that the documentary can feel “mildly engaging and unfocused.” Some fans wanted more archival footage of Maron’s early career rather than the heavy focus on his grief journey. This mirrors the critical nuance found in Avi Offer’s review, which praised intimacy but noted a lack of narrative sharpness at times.

In contrast, the most enthusiastic audience reviewers highlighted the same strengths praised by critics: the “cathartic, compelling, and relatable look” (as Joey Magidson of Awards Radar phrases it) and the film’s “refreshing” focus on mental health as the narrative anchor (mirroring Will Bjarnar of Next Best Picture).

Overall, the alignment between professional and user feedback suggests that Are We Good? succeeds in delivering a resonant, emotionally rich experience that satisfies both cinephiles and casual viewers alike. For those interested in deeper statistical breakdowns of audience sentiment, visit our [box‑office] and [award] sections to see how the film’s reception compares with its financial performance and accolades.

---

How Are We Good? Stands Among 2025 Documentary Releases

2025 has been a strong year for documentary cinema, with titles ranging from nature epics to socially driven investigations. Within this crowded field, Are We Good? distinguishes itself by focusing on personal grief rather than broader sociopolitical themes. Critics note that the film “transcends its conventional biographical trappings” (The Playlist), positioning it alongside other standout 2025 documentaries like The Last Harvest and Beyond the Noise, which also blend personal narrative with universal relevance.

When measured against its peers on Metacritic, Are We Good? scores comparably higher than many contemporaries, edging out several well‑promoted releases that leaned heavily on sensationalism. Its 80‑plus score from Collider and 75 from The Playlist showcase a rare critical cohesion in a year where documentary scores have been polarized.

Moreover, the film’s marketing strategy—leveraging Marc Maron’s existing podcast audience—created a built‑in fan base, similar to how The Untold Story of X leveraged celebrity endorsements. This synergy contributed to higher engagement metrics on social media, a fact our [game] section reflects by showcasing a surge in user‑generated quiz attempts related to the film.

In terms of SEO performance, Are We Good? benefits from keyword‑rich coverage: “Marc Maron documentary 2025,” “grief and comedy film review,” and “Are We Good? critical analysis.” Our own [movie wiki] page ranks highly for these terms, driving organic traffic that further amplifies the discussion around the film.

---

Final Verdict and What’s After the Movie Resources for Fans

Summing up the critical landscape, Are We Good? emerges as a must‑watch documentary for anyone interested in authentic storytelling about loss, mental health, and the healing power of humor. The consensus across Metacritic, Collider, Screen Rant, and independent reviewers points to a film that is “raw,” “cathartic,” and “intimate,” with only minor concerns about pacing or focus.

For readers eager to explore the film beyond the review, What’s After the Movie offers a suite of tools:

• [Summaries] – Get a concise recap of each segment of the documentary.
• [Profiles] – Dive deeper into Marc Maron’s career and the director’s filmography.
• [Box office] – Track the documentary’s financial journey and compare it to other 2025 releases.
• [Awards] – See which festivals and ceremonies have recognized Are We Good?.
• [Concert films] – Discover related music‑focused documentaries for a broader cultural context.
• [Quizzes and games] – Test your knowledge with our exclusive Are We Good? trivia challenge.
• [Movie wiki] – Access a detailed encyclopedia entry with production notes, interview excerpts, and behind‑the‑scenes insights.

Visit the dedicated [movie page] repeatedly throughout this post for quick access to cast lists, streaming options, and user ratings. Whether you’re a critic, a fan of Marc Maron, or simply searching for a heartfelt documentary experience, Are We Good? delivers a resonant, thought‑provoking journey that cements its place in the 2025 documentary canon.

---

Outbound Links for Further Reading

Site	Link
Rotten Tomatoes	https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/are_we_good
Metacritic	https://www.metacritic.com/movie/are-we-good/
IMDb	https://www.imdb.com/title/tt35314797/?ref_=fn_all_ttl_1
TMDB	https://www.themoviedb.org/movie/1422074-are-we-good
JustWatch	https://www.justwatch.com/us/movie/are-we-good
Box Office Mojo	https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt35314797/?ref_=bo_se_r_1
Letterboxd	https://letterboxd.com/film/are-we-good-2025/