Peggy Sue Got Married

As Peggy Sue Bodell (Peggy Sue) steps into the nostalgic atmosphere of her 25-year high school reunion in 1985, accompanied by her daughter Beth, she's met with a mix of warmth and awkwardness. The absence of her estranged husband Charlie is palpable, a poignant reminder of their recent separation following his infidelity.

As Peggy Sue reconnects with old flames Maddy and Carol, she deliberately sidesteps Charlie, opting instead to rekindle the friendships that once defined her high school experience. The evening takes an unexpected turn when the emcee announces the reunion's "king and queen": Richard Norvik, a former class geek turned billionaire inventor, and none other than Peggy Sue herself. Overwhelmed by the sudden recognition, she faints onstage as she's crowned.

When Peggy Sue awakens, she finds herself transported back to 1960, her senior year of high school. Disoriented and confused, she decides to return to her parents' home and blend in seamlessly with her old life. Desperate for answers about her predicament, she turns to Richard Norvik (Richard), hoping his insight can unravel the mystery.

As Peggy Sue navigates her way through this unfamiliar landscape, she begins to forge an unlikely bond with Richard, sharing her story and its bizarre implications. He's initially skeptical but becomes convinced of her claims as she reveals specific details about events yet to come. This newfound understanding prompts Peggy Sue to reevaluate her relationship with Charlie and ultimately decide to end it.

However, before making a clean break, Peggy Sue allows herself one last night of intimacy with Charlie after a party, only for him to panic and remind her of their recent estrangement. Instead of retreating to the comfort of her home, she finds solace in an all-night café, where she encounters Michael Fitzsimmons (Michael), a free-spirited loner who's long been an object of her fascination.

As they share stories and laughter, Peggy Sue discovers that beneath their quirky exteriors lies a deep connection. They part ways on Michael's motorcycle, only to reunite under the stars for a passionate night of exploration.

The next evening finds Peggy Sue at a local music bar, where Michael reveals his desire to take two women, including her, to Utah for a polyamorous relationship. She politely declines, suggesting he find inspiration in their shared experience instead. Fate intervenes when Charlie takes the stage, and Peggy Sue gains a new perspective on her former lover as she watches him perform.

Meanwhile, Charlie's music career receives a lukewarm response from a visiting agent, who fails to see the artistic potential in his performances. As the evening wears on, Peggy Sue finds herself at a crossroads, forced to confront the complexities of her relationships and the choices that lie ahead.

The following day, Peggy Sue attempts to have an open conversation with Charlie, but his frustration over failing to secure a record deal boils over, leaving her feeling the sting of his upset. Seeking solace, she makes her way to Richard's side, expressing her desire to break free from the toxic cycle that's been perpetuating in their lives - particularly for Charlie, whose passion for music was ultimately stifled by her pregnancy. With this realization weighing heavily on her conscience, Richard extends an olive branch in the form of a proposal, but Peggy Sue declines, recognizing that she and Richard are too young to embark on such a significant life-altering commitment, not to mention the potential impact it could have on his future aspirations.

As her 18th birthday approaches, Peggy Sue decides to pay a visit to her grandparents, sharing the tumultuous tale of her past with them. Her grandmother's admission that she possesses psychic abilities sparks Peggy Sue's curiosity, leading her to confide in her grandfather about her extraordinary experiences. It is then that he takes her on a journey to his Masonic lodge, where the members gather to perform an ancient ritual designed to transport her back to 1985. As the lights flicker and dim, Charlie enters the lodge, seizes Peggy Sue, and makes a hasty exit with her, leaving the others inside convinced that the ritual has been successful.

Back in the present, Charlie reveals his decision to give up singing and instead join his family's business, claiming 10% of its profits. He then presents Peggy Sue with the locket she wore at the film's inception, accompanied by a heartfelt proposal and a poignant reminder of their past. As she gazes upon the baby pictures of themselves inside the locket, Peggy Sue is struck by an epiphany - they are meant to be together. The couple's passion is rekindled as they surrender to their desires.

Peggy Sue awakens in a hospital bed back in 1985, Charlie by her side. As she recovers from her ordeal, he presents her with Michael's written work, dedicated "To Peggy Sue and a Starry Night" - a testament to the possibility that she may have indeed traveled through time. Regretting his past infidelity, Charlie pleads for forgiveness and another chance at love. Peggy Sue reflects on her grandfather's words about the power of her grandmother's strudel in holding their family together, prompting her to invite Charlie to dinner and offer a warm smile: "I'll bake a strudel."