Remember the Night 1940
Directed by
Mitchell Leisen
Made by
Paramount Pictures
Remember the Night Plot Summary
Read the complete plot summary and ending explained for Remember the Night (1940). From turning points to emotional moments, uncover what really happened and why it matters.
As Lee Leander awaits her trial in a jail cell, accused of stealing a beautiful bracelet from a jewelry store in New York City, she finds herself at the mercy of John “Jack” Sargent, the Assistant District Attorney assigned to prosecute her case. The timing of the trial, right before Christmas, feels particularly harsh, adding a layer of irony as the festive season approaches. In a clever move, Jack exploits a technicality to delay the trial, much to Lee’s frustration.
Haunted by guilt over Lee’s extended stay behind bars, Jack decides to ask bondsman Fat Mike to post her bail. However, Fat Mike misunderstands Jack’s intentions, believing that he is interested in more than just helping Lee, and instead delivers her to Jack’s apartment. Their shared roots from Indiana bring them closer, and Jack generously offers Lee the chance to visit her mother for Christmas. Unfortunately, their trip takes an unexpected twist, leaving them lost in a Pennsylvania field where they must spend the night.
Upon waking, they are confronted by an angry landowner who arrests them for trespassing and damages, leading them to a hostile justice of the peace. Using her quick wit, Lee manages to create a diversion by starting a fire, providing them with an opportunity to escape. Eventually, they reach Lee’s mother’s house, only to be met with disdain and negativity, forcing Lee to reckon with the lack of a supportive family.
Jack’s conscience gnaws at him, prompting the decision to bring Lee to his family for Christmas. Initially hesitant, they are welcomed with open arms by his relatives, including his cousin Willie, aunt Emma, and mother. The festive atmosphere culminates in a romantic New Year’s Eve kiss between Jack and Lee at a barn dance, but their blossoming relationship faces challenges when Jack’s mother unexpectedly visits Lee’s room.
During this encounter, his mother opens up about the family’s history and the sacrifices they made for a better life, stressing the importance of education and the looming consequences of Lee’s past on Jack’s future. With a heavy heart, Lee agrees to step back, prioritizing Jack’s career over her desires, as midnight strikes.
Taking the long way back to New York through the breathtaking scenery of Niagara Falls, Jack has the chance to confess his undeniable love for Lee. Despite his heartfelt pleadings for her to abandon the bail system and embrace a fresh start with him, Lee firmly rejects the idea. Returning to the busy city, Jack takes a bold approach in court, employing intense interrogation methods to garner sympathy from the jury in a desperate attempt to clear Lee of the charges. Yet, his boss, aware of the scandalous affair, watches from the sidelines, fully understanding the potential ramifications on Jack’s career.
As the trial reaches its peak, Lee, cognizant of the tightrope they balance upon due to public scrutiny, makes a drastic choice: she changes her plea to guilty. Chaos erupts in the courtroom as she is led away in handcuffs, leaving Jack in a state of devastation. In a heart-wrenching moment, he asks Lee to reconsider their future together, even suggesting marriage right away. Her response, while warm, is resolute; she insists that if Jack’s feelings remain true after her time in prison and thoughtful reflection, then they may discuss the idea of marriage. With a heavy heart, Jack pledges to support Lee through her sentencing, extending his hand in a gesture of solidarity as she departs.
Remember the Night Timeline
Follow the complete movie timeline of Remember the Night (1940) with every major event in chronological order. Great for understanding complex plots and story progression.
Lee's Arrest
Lee Leander finds herself in a jail cell, facing trial for allegedly stealing a beautiful bracelet from a jewelry store in New York City. This moment marks the beginning of her struggles and highlights the harsh realities of her situation, especially as the trial approaches during the festive season right before Christmas.
Jack Delays the Trial
John 'Jack' Sargent, the Assistant District Attorney assigned to Lee's case, cleverly exploits a legal technicality to postpone the trial. This decision frustrates Lee, who is anxious to prove her innocence and longs for her freedom before the holidays.
Jack's Guilt
Haunted by the thought of Lee spending Christmas in jail, Jack decides to approach bondsman Fat Mike to help secure her release. Fat Mike, however, misinterprets Jack's intentions, leading to a series of misunderstandings about Jack's feelings toward Lee.
Christmas Visit
After Lee is bailed out, Jack takes her to visit her mother for Christmas. However, their plans go awry when they become lost in a Pennsylvania field, forcing them to spend an uncomfortable night outdoors, showcasing the unpredictability of their journey together.
Confrontation with the Landowner
Upon waking in the field, Lee and Jack are confronted by an angry landowner who arrests them for trespassing. This incident leads to a tense encounter with a hostile justice of the peace, illustrating the precariousness of their situation and the challenges they must navigate.
Lee's Quick Thinking
Using her quick wit, Lee creates a diversion by starting a fire, allowing her and Jack to escape from their legal troubles. This moment highlights Lee's resourcefulness and brings an element of tension and excitement to their adventure.
Visit to Lee's Family
After successfully escaping, Lee and Jack reach Lee's mother's house, only to be met with negativity and disdain. This encounter forces Lee to face the harsh realities of her family dynamics, adding emotional depth to her character.
Jack’s Family Christmas
Jack brings Lee to his family for Christmas. She is initially hesitant but ultimately finds acceptance and warmth among his relatives, including Jack's cousin Willie and aunt Emma, which contrasts sharply with her own familial experiences.
New Year's Eve Dance
As the festive atmosphere builds, Jack and Lee share a romantic kiss during a New Year's Eve barn dance. This moment signifies a deepening of their relationship, despite the looming complications that their situations entail.
Jack's Mother's Visit
Jack's mother unexpectedly visits Lee’s room, opening a conversation about family sacrifices and education. This pivotal moment forces Lee to reflect on her past and the implications it might have on Jack's future, adding weight to her character arc.
Lee’s Heart-Wrenching Decision
Feeling the pressure of Jack's family's expectations and her troubled past, Lee decides to step back from their relationship. She resolves to prioritize Jack's future over her own desires, complicating their romance as they face uncertainty.
Scenic Journey Back
On their return trip to New York, Jack takes the scenic route through Niagara Falls, hoping to express his true feelings for Lee. Despite his heartfelt pleas for her to start fresh together, Lee rejects his offer, illustrating the complexity of their love.
The Courtroom Showdown
Back in the city, Jack employs intense interrogation tactics in court as he tries to appeal to the jury's sympathy to clear Lee of charges. This moment showcases Jack's desperation and the ethical dilemmas he faces due to his feelings for Lee.
Lee Changes Her Plea
In a surprising turn of events, Lee decides to change her plea to guilty, leading to chaos in the courtroom. This drastic choice leaves Jack devastated and highlights the struggles between love, sacrifice, and personal integrity.
A Heartfelt Promise
As Lee is led away in handcuffs, Jack pleads with her to reconsider their future and even suggests marriage. Though her response is warm, she insists they must wait until after her prison time to discuss such matters, underscoring the theme of resilience and hope in their relationship.
Remember the Night Characters
Explore all characters from Remember the Night (1940). Get detailed profiles with their roles, arcs, and key relationships explained.
Lee Leander (Sterling Holloway)
Lee Leander is a complex character marked by her resilience and wit. Accused of theft, her tough exterior hides deeper vulnerabilities stemming from her troubled past and lack of familial support. Throughout the story, she demonstrates intelligence and courage, making choices that significantly impact her life and relationships.
John 'Jack' Sargent (Fred MacMurray)
Jack Sargent is portrayed as a compassionate yet conflicted Assistant District Attorney. Torn between his professional obligations and his feelings for Lee, he embodies a moral struggle that deepens as the story unfolds. His character showcases growth as he confronts his emotions and considers the implications of love against societal expectations.
Remember the Night Settings
Learn where and when Remember the Night (1940) takes place. Explore the film’s settings, era, and how they shape the narrative.
Time period
Christmas Season, 1930s
The movie is set during the Christmas season, a time often associated with joy and family gatherings. However, this festive backdrop juxtaposes the characters' struggles and dilemmas. The 1930s context highlights societal challenges, reflecting moral dilemmas faced during that era.
Location
New York City, Pennsylvania, Niagara Falls
The story primarily unfolds in New York City, known for its vibrant culture and bustling streets. A significant portion also takes place in the serene landscapes of Pennsylvania, where a surprising overnight adventure occurs, offering a stark contrast. Additionally, Niagara Falls serves as a picturesque backdrop, symbolizing both beauty and the turbulent emotions of the characters.
Remember the Night Themes
Discover the main themes in Remember the Night (1940). Analyze the deeper meanings, emotional layers, and social commentary behind the film.
💔
Love and Sacrifice
The theme of love and sacrifice is central to the narrative as Jack grapples with his deep feelings for Lee, while also recognizing the consequences of their relationship on his future. Lee's decision to prioritize Jack's career over her own desires emphasizes the emotional weight of sacrifice. Their love story challenges traditional expectations and presents the complexities of romantic choices amid societal judgment.
⚖️
Justice and Morality
Justice and morality frequently intersect throughout the film as Jack navigates the legal system while being emotionally invested in Lee's fate. The courtroom scenarios critique the difficulties within the justice system, showcasing moral conflicts between professional duty and personal affection. Lee's ultimate decision to plead guilty raises questions about guilt, redemption, and the pursuit of a just outcome.
Remember the Night Spoiler-Free Summary
Discover the spoiler-free summary of Remember the Night (1940). Get a concise overview without any spoilers.
In the glow of an early‑winter holiday, a bustling New York courtroom becomes the unlikely meeting place for two very different lives. John Sargent, a seasoned assistant district attorney whose reputation is built on unflinching resolve, finds his routine interrupted when he offers a small mercy to a young woman caught in the throes of a petty crime. The gesture—an unexpected act of kindness during a season that usually highlights stark contrasts—sets the stage for a journey far beyond the city’s cold, procedural corridors.
Across the tracks, Lee Leander is a spirited, quick‑witted soul whose world is rooted in the modest, close‑knit towns of the Midwest. She carries the weight of a family she barely knows and a future that feels both constrained and hopeful. When John extends an invitation to ride home for the holidays, the simple offer becomes a bridge between two disparate worlds: the rigid expectations of a legal career and the unguarded warmth of small‑town life. Their connection is immediate, rooted in humor, curiosity, and a shared longing for something beyond their current selves.
The film balances the crisp, festive atmosphere of Christmas with an undercurrent of introspection, letting the audience feel both the sparkle of new romance and the quiet tension of societal pressure. As the characters navigate families, traditions, and the inevitable doubts that accompany any crossing of personal and professional lines, the story unfolds with a gentle, hopeful tone. It invites viewers to wonder whether a single act of generosity can rewrite the narrative of two people whose lives, until now, have been written in very different ink.
Movies with Similar Twists and Themes
Uncover films that echo the narrative beats, emotional arcs, or dramatic twists of the one you're exploring. These recommendations are handpicked based on story depth, thematic resonance, and spoiler-worthy moments — perfect for fans who crave more of the same intrigue.
Featured on this page
What's After the Movie?
Not sure whether to stay after the credits? Find out!
Explore Our Movie Platform
New Movie Releases (2026)
Famous Movie Actors
Top Film Production Studios
Movie Plot Summaries & Endings
Major Movie Awards & Winners
Best Concert Films & Music Documentaries
Movie Collections and Curated Lists
© 2026 What's After the Movie. All rights reserved.