The Death and Life of Marsha P. Johnson 2017

Marsha P. Johnson warmly welcomes us at the docks where Christopher Street meets the Hudson River. A passerby recognizes Marsha P. Johnson, expressing that everyone knows her for her fearless approach to identity, whether she chooses to dress in drag or as a man, embracing her authentic self. This admiration highlights Johnson’s incredible courage and the genuine freedom she embodies.

However, beneath this vibrant exterior lies a darker reality. Despite her local fame, Marsha lives in poverty and battles with mental illness. Ever since the Stonewall Rebellion, she has passionately fought for the rights of gay, lesbian, and gender nonconforming individuals. Tragically, we discover that Marsha has been murdered, yet the police dismiss her death as a mere suicide, quickly closing the case without further investigation.

The community erupts in outrage, sparking the creation of a people’s memorial and a protest march. Activists take to the streets, demanding justice not only for Marsha but also for countless others facing violence within the LGBT community. Justice, however, appears to be nothing more than an elusive dream.

Fast forward twenty-five years, we meet Victoria Cruz, who dedicates herself to seeking justice for murdered trans women. Victoria reaches out to Marsha’s family, friends, and fellow activists, advocating tirelessly for the reopening of Marsha’s cold case. In her quest, she interviews retired police officers and individuals who were last with Marsha, uncovering a web of Mafia threats, corrupt law enforcement, and internal divisions within the many communities that once cherished her.

As we delve into the past, we witness Marsha during her lifetime, alongside her close friend Sylvia Rivera, as they stand at the forefront of activism during the first Christopher Street Liberation Rally and other pivotal Gay Rights events in New York City. This footage captures moments both rare and in extended form, showcasing their unwavering commitment to social justice.

Despite the passage of time, the quest for justice remains fraught with challenges. We experience the cumulative frustration and fatigue of those who continue to fight, feeling the emotional toll this struggle has exacted on survivors. In a deeply reflective journey, we walk alongside Marsha and Victoria, working to piece together the events leading to Marsha’s untimely death, honoring both the deceased and the living who continue the fight for recognition and equality.