
In 1843 Southold, New York, a young woman faces scrutiny after her grandmother's death. The investigation uncovers a hidden past, revealing Mary’s constrained life and a secret relationship with Eleanor, the household maid. Their forbidden love blossoms in secrecy, but discovery leads to a dangerous situation, as they confront a community driven by fear and determined to punish what they deem sinful. They must navigate a complex web of deceit and face the consequences of their actions.
Does The Last Thing Mary Saw have end credit scenes?
No!
The Last Thing Mary Saw does not have end credit scenes. You can leave when the credits roll.
Explore the complete cast of The Last Thing Mary Saw, including both lead and supporting actors. Learn who plays each character, discover their past roles and achievements, and find out what makes this ensemble cast stand out in the world of film and television.

Judith Roberts
The Matriarch

Isabelle Fuhrman
Eleanor

Rory Culkin
The Intruder

Stefanie Scott
Mary

Carolyn McCormick
Agnes

Daniel Pearce
The Interrogator

Dawn McGee
Ann

Elijah Rayman
Matthew

Matthew Stannah
Deputy 2

Michael Laurence
Randolph

P.J. Sosko
Theodore (The Guard)

Philip Hoffman
Deputy 1

Sebastian Beacon
Deputy 3

Shane Coffey
Eustace's Son

Stephen Lee Anderson
The Grandfather

Tommy Buck
Eustace
Discover where to watch The Last Thing Mary Saw online, including streaming platforms, rental options, and official sources. Compare reviews, ratings, and in-depth movie information across sites like IMDb, TMDb, Wikipedia or Rotten Tomatoes.
See how The Last Thing Mary Saw is rated across major platforms like IMDb, Metacritic, and TMDb. Compare audience scores and critic reviews to understand where The Last Thing Mary Saw stands among top-rated movies in its genre.
The film presents a mixed impression, with occasional atmospheric strengths offset by pervasive narrative and character shortcomings. Critics note effective period detail and a moody visual palette, yet repeatedly describe the plot as unconvincing and the pacing as sluggish. User feedback mirrors this divide, citing strong performances in isolated moments while criticizing generic storytelling and limited emotional resonance. Consequently, the overall experience feels uneven, offering moments of intrigue but lacking sustained impact.
The Movie Echo Score Breakdown for The Last Thing Mary Saw
Art & Craft
In terms of art and craft, the film displays noteworthy period detail and an atmospheric visual style praised by several reviewers. However, the dark cinematography often obscures action, and editing choices are described as contributing to a lack of clarity. The production design receives commendation, yet the overall visual execution is seen as uneven, resulting in a modest assessment of its artistic execution.
Character & Emotion
When evaluating character and emotion, performances are acknowledged as competent, with some critics highlighting a strong ensemble cast. Nevertheless, many reviewers point to shallow character development and poor chemistry, making it difficult for audiences to connect emotionally. The limited depth of the protagonists and underdeveloped relationships diminish the overall impact, leading to a slightly below‑average character rating.
Story & Flow
Story and flow receive the lowest appraisal, as critics and users alike describe the plot as generic, sluggish, and lacking cohesion. While a few note a compelling second act, the majority cite unconvincing narrative choices, uneven pacing, and an unsatisfying resolution. The originality of the premise is recognized, yet execution flaws dominate, resulting in a weak overall story rating.
Sensory Experience
Sensory experience benefits from an evocative atmosphere and commendable cinematography in certain scenes, according to several reviewers. Sound design and visual mood are highlighted as strengths, though occasional over‑darkness impairs clarity. The soundtrack and overall sensory cohesion are generally well‑received, placing this aspect above average despite minor criticisms.
Rewatch Factor
Rewatch factor is limited, with many reviewers indicating the film lacks lasting appeal and sufficient novelty for repeat viewings. Some positive remarks mention memorable moments and a strong concluding act, yet the prevailing view emphasizes generic storytelling and insufficient scares. Consequently, the film’s replay value is judged to be low.
52
Metascore
5.3
User Score
71%
TOMATOMETER
49%
User Score
62
%
User Score
2.8
From 3 fan ratings
1.25/5
From 4 fan ratings
It appears The Last Thing Mary Saw does not have a summary available yet. Please consider requesting one.

Coming soon on iOS and Android
From blockbusters to hidden gems — dive into movie stories anytime, anywhere. Save your favorites, discover plots faster, and never miss a twist again.
Sign up to be the first to know when we launch. Your email stays private — always.
Watch official trailers, exclusive clips, cast interviews, and behind-the-scenes footage from The Last Thing Mary Saw. Dive deeper into the making of the film, its standout moments, and key production insights.
Explore the various alternative titles, translations, and other names used for The Last Thing Mary Saw across different regions and languages. Understand how the film is marketed and recognized worldwide.
What's After the Movie?
Not sure whether to stay after the credits? Find out!
Explore Our Movie Platform
New Movie Releases (2025)
Famous Movie Actors
Top Film Production Studios
Movie Plot Summaries & Endings
Major Movie Awards & Winners
Best Concert Films & Music Documentaries
Movie Collections and Curated Lists
© 2025 What's After the Movie. All rights reserved.