The film begins with Rachel (Lindsay Lohan) compelling her mother, Lilly (Felicity Huffman), to halt their car during a trip to Lilly’s mother’s home in Idaho, where Rachel is to spend the summer due to her rebellious behavior. After departing from the vehicle, Rachel finds herself resting beneath a billboard, where she meets the charming Harlan. Startled by him while he checks her vitals, Rachel quickly leaps into the car of Simon, the local veterinarian and de facto medical advisor, who has stopped to investigate the scene.

The dynamic between Lilly and her mother, Georgia (Jane Fonda), is notably strained, prompting Lilly to leave and forcing Rachel to navigate Georgia’s stringent household rules. Her daily life becomes meticulously scheduled—breakfast at 8, dinner at 6, following the so-called “Georgia Rule.” Despite their initial conflicts, Rachel takes a job assisting Simon, drawn in by an unexpected attraction to him.

During her time in Idaho, Rachel crosses paths with Harlan once more. On a fishing outing, he confesses his virginity and discusses his religious commitment to a two-year mission. Manipulating the situation to her advantage, Rachel persuades him that exploring her body does not violate his moral boundaries, leading to an unexpected encounter that becomes emotionally charged. When Harlan inquires about her motives, Rachel chillingly states she was “looking for someone to say no,” paving the way for a series of uncomfortable revelations.

As Rachel grapples with her tumultuous relationship with both her mother and grandmother, she confronts Simon about his wife’s passing, and in a gripping moment, discloses that she was molested by her step-father, Arnold, since she was twelve. This bombshell forces Georgia to inform Lilly, which ignites a fiery confrontation. Torn between truth and deception, Rachel initially denies her claims but later confesses to Georgia, complicating an already fragile web of lies.

When Arnold comes to confront Rachel, the tension mounts, revealing a dark past they’ve shared, gullibly recorded for leverage by someone else. Determined to maintain her mother’s happiness, Rachel opts to continue the facade. However, as Arnold’s disturbing behavior escalates, Lilly discovers the truth herself, leading to a confrontation where Arnold alleges that Rachel seduced him at age twelve—blaming Lilly’s alcoholism for his actions.

The film culminates with a poignant reunion between Rachel and Lilly, capturing their fraught yet healing relationship as they embrace on the roadside, leaving viewers with a profound sense of complexity surrounding family bonds and secrets. THE END